Everlane Vs Madewell: Which Denim Brand Fits You Best?

We only feature products that we hope you will love. We may earn a commission if you decide to make a purchase through our links, at no cost to you.  

Minimalism and sustainability are two things that many fashion brands are aiming to achieve. If you’re looking to buy new denim, check out our guide to Everlane vs Madewell.

You’ve heard of Old Navy. Urban Outfitters, Good American, American Eagle, and Free People. What do these clothing brands have in common? They’re all powerhouses when it comes to sourcing denim jeans, but most importantly, they’re some of the best places to get high-quality casualwear at great prices – which is what everyone is after.

However, they’re not the only brands that exist in the fashion market – in fact, there are hundreds. You might have heard of Everlane and Madewell, but if you haven’t taken a chance on their denim offerings yet, now’s a good time to read up on them before making a decision.

Everlane and Madewell are two popular brands that have an impressive denim collections, but they’re far from identical.

Before you decide to shop at one store over the other, it’s essential to get a sense of what each brand is all about. That way, you can be sure you’re investing in pieces that actually match your lifestyle.

In this post, we’ll compare Everlane vs Madewell by focusing on their price points, styles, sizing charts, sustainability efforts and more. Let’s get started on helping you find your new favorite jeans!

Get to Know Everlane

Everlane is a clothing brand that sells high-quality, minimalist clothing at affordable prices. The brand’s mission is to create a sustainable, ethical supply chain. Everlane offers simple styles of basics in neutral colors and designs that will last through the seasons.


The company was founded by Michael Preysman and Jesse Farmer in 2010 as part of an experiment to make ethically sourced clothing entirely transparently priced—the price tag includes the cost of materials and labor from start to finish so you know exactly how much your item costs without any hidden markups along the way.

Through this practice, Everlane aims to foster trust between customers and the company by building transparency into its business model from day one.

They claim to produce “ethically made clothing,” as seen on their retailer website. Everlane is currently headquartered in San Francisco, California, with stores in New York City, Boston, Los Angeles, Austin, and Palo Alto.

Say Hello To Madewell

Madewell is originally a workwear clothing brand that was founded in 1937. Now, this is where the history gets quite tricky – the brand was re-born in 2006 as a sister label under J.Crew.

Mickey Drexler, the CEO of J.Crew, purchased the trademark, the logo, and the history itself of the original Madewell that was founded in 1937.


So essentially, the original Madewell clothing brand started in 1937, and the 2006 Madewell created by J.Crew and Mickey Drexler used the original brand as a point of inspiration.

Madewell is inspired by cool and classic American styles. The brand is well-known for its high-quality denim and other clothing items. The brand has also been popularized as a result of many collaborations with celebrities and influencers. For example, Taylor Swift has been spotted wearing quite a number of Madewell pieces over the years. 

Everlane VS Madewell: How Do They Compare?

Now that we’ve discussed their brand history, let’s dive deeper into the differences between these two brands.

 
 
3 Brilliant Ways To Save Hundreds On Luxury Products
And no, these don't include buying secondhand or outlet – we're sharing 3 legitimate ways to get your favorite luxe products up to 25% cheaper.
Thank you for subscribing! Keep an eye on your inbox for updates.
 

1. Price

When it comes to price, Madewell is slightly more expensive than Everlane, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. If you have more money, it might be worth investing in a pair of Madewell jeans.

A quick run-through on each website shows that Everlane jeans retail for around $100, while Madewell’s jeans typically retail for $138, although you can find styles for around $100 as well.

But don’t let this turn you off – Madewell is always holding sales for their denim, so you don’t necessarily need to pay full price.

2. Styles

A quick glance at both brands’ websites shows that Madewell is the clear winner. At the moment, the brand offers almost 300 different styles, whereas Everlane only has about 70 denim pieces in its collection.

It’s clear to see that Madewell has a wider range of styles, including perfect vintage fit jeans, straight leg jeans, wide leg jeans, flare jeans, curvy jeans, baggy jeans, demi-boot jeans, boyjeans, skinny jeans, high rise jeans, and even maternity jeans – something that Everlane does not offer in their website.

Madewell tends to lean more toward vintage styles and wide-leg pants that are great if you’ve got curves: they’re perfect for hiding any imperfections while still looking stylishly casual with your favorite pair of sneakers or boots at the end of a long day at work.

As for Everlane, the brand currently offers skinny fit, relaxed, straight, curvy fit, and wide styles among others.

3. Sizing

Everlane has sizes from 23-35, while Madewell offers 23-37 (depending on the product), so finding the right size for you is not really a problem. However, we’re still going to recommend you do your own research on the specific item you want to purchase before buying it.

The one big difference between Madewell and Everlane jeans is that with Madewell, you can choose between regular, petite, tall and taller options, whereas browsing products in theese categories is more difficult over at Everlane.

Don’t get us wrong, you can still choose between petite and tall sizes on certain jean styles like the 90s cheeky jean, but not all styles have this option, and there isn’t an easy way to browse all petite jeans, or all tall jeans in one go.

4. Sustainability Efforts

Everlane’s commitment to transparency is evident in its supply chain. On their sustainability page, you can find out the conditions of their factories, as well as the sustainability practices put in place.

One of the coolest initiatives on the page is that Everlane has promised to stop using new plastics by 2021 – while they haven’t fully succeeded, they state that they are 90% there, and give clear examples of what they have achieved.

Madewell, on the other hand, has also been working toward sustainable practices by selling second-hand denim. Madewell has a social responsibility page but hasn’t delved into specific details about how its business model aligns with this goal yet besides stating, “we are committed to being responsible stewards of our planet.”

Madewell aims to have 100% of their “key fibers” be sustainably sourced and free of virgin plastic by 2025, as well as to be carbon-neutral by 2030.

Our Favorite Everlane Vs Madewell Denim Pieces

Now that we have talked about the brands’ histories and their main differences, let’s compare their pieces! Everlane and Madewell both offer minimalistic styles that you can definitely add to your capsule wardrobe.

Jeans
Everlane way high jeans
Get these jeans on Everlane
Everlane VS Madewell: Straight jeans from Madewell
Get these jeans on Madewell

The Rigid Way-High Jean from Everlane retails for $108, and it comes in five different washes: vintage light wash, worn-in blue, worn-in-black, rich indigo, and paint splatter.

According to Everlane, these are the brand’s highest-rise jeans, and they sit nicely above the belly button.  The jeans hold in at the waist and hips and feature a straight fit from hip to ankle.

Additionally, it is a non-stretch fabric, made of premium 100% organic cotton, which gives off a heavier vintage feel. 

On the other hand, the Perfect Vintage Straight Jean: Carpenter Edition from Madewell retail for $148, and they only come in one light wash. 

These jeans are a workwear take on the brand’s cult-favorite straight-legged Perfect Vintage Jeans, and they feature carpenter details like a hammer loop and a side pocket for additional gear. 

These jeans are made from premium organic non-stretch cotton without chemical fertilizers and pesticides. 

They pair perfectly with dressy blouses, floral crop tops, chic sandals, and even formal button-downs.

Our Verdict

Both brands offer timeless and trendy pieces that will last you for years to come. After analyzing both brands, we’d say that we prefer Madewell over Everlane, thanks to the fact that they offer more styles and sizes – you’re more likely to find what you want from Madewell!

We hope you enjoyed our analysis of Madewell vs Everlane jeans! For more similar articles, check out the posts below.

Get More Fashion Ideas

Girlfriend Vs Boyfriend Jeans: What’s The Difference?

Gucci Vs Coach: Which Brand Is Right For You?

Versace Jeans Vs Versace: What’s The Difference?

Browse All Fashion Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.